|
DIARY OF A DIG – WEEK 2
BRAEMORE SQUARE MAY 2008
The second week of our
excavation at Braemore Square has produced more questions than answers
and, in true ‘Time Team’ tradition, the last two days were marked by
exciting discoveries and conflicting theories. At the beginning of the
week most of us had abandoned the idea of the feature being a ‘hut
circle’ but, as digging progressed, it became clearer that some kind
of human activity had been going on, the nature of which still has to
be determined.
To follow up an interesting
line of large vertical stones, a new trench 5 was opened on the
north-west side of the circle. This was eventually joined to trench 2,
revealing the continuation of laid slabs and two small cell-like
structures. On Day 8 of the Dig, two possible stake-holes in the
cobbling and a possible post-hole were found. In these trenches the
dark soil, which contained much charcoal, ran underneath the large
stones of the dyke and the slabbed ‘paving’.
Throughout all the trenches,
layers were stripped systematically and each recorded carefully in a
variety of ways. They were photographed and plans of 1-metre areas
were drawn and the levels within them measured using a ‘Dumpy’.
Sections of the trenches were measured and hand-drawn.
Our work on the cairn
(trench 3) came to an end. Having cut through a quadrant, it appeared
that a natural rise of stones had been used as the base for a
clearance cairn, with large stones piled at the bottom. There was no
clear differentiation between the natural surface and the base of the
cairn. There were no finds apart from a small piece of relatively
modern glazed pottery and no dateable evidence. Whilst the lack of
finds was disappointing, our work has established that it was not
built on a burial or an earlier structure and was a clearance cairn of
indeterminate age. The trench was filled in, turf replaced and even
some bluebells were replanted on top.
Trench 4 (once thought to
show the entrance to the circle) showed no sign of an entrance passage
and did not appear to represent part of a circular wall. There is some
evidence of a much-robbed wall but its relationship to the other
features on the site is unclear.
By Thursday, the penultimate
day of excavation, a new theory had emerged. The supposed post-holes
and stake-holes had been dismissed leading to the conclusion that the
structure was unlikely to be a dwelling at all. The suggestion was put
forward that it could be a ritual cairn. Evidence to support this
argument was the presence of pockets of burnt material and groups of
deliberately deposited quartz pebbles. Corroboration appeared to have
been found by the excavation in the centre of the circle of a small
setting of stones containing 3 quartz stones on top of a rich charcoal
layer – a ritual offering?
Other evidence to support
the ritual cairn theory is the total lack of pottery, stone tools or
occupation debris. Either the site does not represent a dwelling or
the people living there were very tidy.
By the end of the
excavation, no single theory convinced everyone. Whilst the ritual
cairn idea is attractive, the possibility of a very robbed, disturbed
hut circle has not been ruled out. The rich charcoal deposits and
slabbed area in the north-west section may indicate the entrance to
the hut. No date can be ascribed at present but carbon-14 dating of
the charcoal finds may establish whether we are looking at human
activity from 1000BC or 1000AD or a Boy Scout camp from the last
century. The results will help determine whether the excavation
continues next year.
Those of us who have
participated in the excavation have had a tremendous time and learned
a great deal, aided by the fact that the weather has been glorious and
the midges only appeared in the last two days. Thanks are due to the
official sponsors and the companies and individuals in Ullapool who
provided material or edible support. Cathy Dagg, our site directrice,
must be specially thanked for her patient instruction and continual
optimism. She chivvied us along with gentle hints, “I don’t want you
to move, I want you to work.”
We owe thanks to all the
volunteers who gave up their time and came from all parts of the
country. Thanks also to Eddie Hughes, the congenial land-owner, who
allowed us to dig up his fields. And of course our greatest
appreciation goes to Anna Welti, without whose unflagging effort and
enthusiasm, the project would never have taken place.
|